>you People cant go for 5 minutes with wrath clogging your mind
  • Welcome. Registering and having your account be approved may take a while since there's only one guy checking and approving accounts and guestposts
  • Boards are being moved around and added. Leave feedback in this thread and let jannies move your threads

The Dump

Status
Not open for further replies.
According to the majority of Islamic scholars, Asma was 10 years older than Aisha. Also according to these scholars, Asma died at the age of 100 in 695 CE or 73 Hijra. This would make her birthdate in 595 CE and consequently Aisha's birthdate in 605 CE.
The Year of Sorrow occured in either 619 or 623 CE where Khadija (the Prophet's first wife) passed away. The Prophet married Aisha shortly after this time. This would therefore make Aisha either 14 when the marriage was written and 17 at consummation, or 18 when the marriage was written and 21 at consummation.

1749848605706.png
1749848627078.png

you can take this how youd like.
 
According to the majority of Islamic scholars, Asma was 10 years older than Aisha. Also according to these scholars, Asma died at the age of 100 in 695 CE or 73 Hijra. This would make her birthdate in 595 CE and consequently Aisha's birthdate in 605 CE.
The Year of Sorrow occured in either 619 or 623 CE where Khadija (the Prophet's first wife) passed away. The Prophet married Aisha shortly after this time. This would therefore make Aisha either 14 when the marriage was written and 17 at consummation, or 18 when the marriage was written and 21 at consummation.

View attachment 18455
View attachment 18457

you can take this how youd like.
 
According to the majority of Islamic scholars, Asma was 10 years older than Aisha. Also according to these scholars, Asma died at the age of 100 in 695 CE or 73 Hijra. This would make her birthdate in 595 CE and consequently Aisha's birthdate in 605 CE.
The Year of Sorrow occured in either 619 or 623 CE where Khadija (the Prophet's first wife) passed away. The Prophet married Aisha shortly after this time. This would therefore make Aisha either 14 when the marriage was written and 17 at consummation, or 18 when the marriage was written and 21 at consummation.

View attachment 18455
View attachment 18457

you can take this how youd like.
isnt the claim of asma being 10 years older disputed? i would have to investigate a bit but ive heard the claim relies on weak assumptions, i dont think its ever stated directly in any hadith collections
i think its mentioned in al tabaris book? but its a secondary source and im pretty sure i recall hearing that he did not verify chains of narration as he prioritized historical compilation or some raisin, and his book could be a mix of daif sahih and even fabricated narrations
there are like over 10 hadiths most sahih that are extremely important for sunnis (90% of the muslim population) specificallt stating that aisha was exactly 9 at consummation, and some of them stating that she played with dolls with her friends which seems like a child-like thing to do
also you literally got banned over saying that "age of mind" is a thing diddy ahh blud
 
Last edited:
isnt the claim of asma being 10 years older disputed? i would have to investigate a bit but ive heard the claim relies on weak assumptions, i dont think its ever stated directly in any hadith collections
i think its mentioned in al tabaris book? but its a secondary source and im pretty sure i recall hearing that he did not verify chains of narration as he prioritized historical compilation or some raisin, and his book could be a mix of daif sahih and even fabricated narrations
there are like over 10 hadiths most sahih that are extremely important for sunnis (90% of the muslim population) specificallt stating that aisha was exactly 9 at consummation, and some of them stating that she played with dolls with her friends which seems like a child-like thing to do
also you literally got banned over saying that "age of mind" is a thing diddy ahh blud
i explicity stated child marriage is bad
and will continue to
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom