The hypothetical is absurd on its face, which is exactly why it’s revealing.
Claus was Austrian, of European ancestry, with the physical traits that every racial classification system used in the 20th century (and most today) would call white. Living in Argentina after 1945 (itself a fringe conspiracy theory) would not change his ancestry or appearance. Argentina has a large population of European descent; relocating there does not make someone non-white any more than a Japanese person moving to Brazil stops being East Asian.
What the hypothetical actually tests
It asks whether people would abandon a basic, observable fact (Claus’s European ancestry and phenotype) because of a location or a preferred narrative. The fact that this question can be posed at all points to several real tendencies in current culture:
Race as narrative rather than description: In some circles, racial categories are treated as flexible tools for moral or political storytelling rather than attempts to describe ancestry and physical variation. If the “correct” story requires Claus not to be white, then the category is adjusted. This is the same mechanism that produces claims that certain groups are “not really” what their ancestry and appearance indicate when it becomes inconvenient.
Motivated reasoning over evidence: People routinely subordinate clear historical and biological facts to identity frameworks. The willingness to deny something as straightforward as Claus’s European origins because of a hypothetical Argentine exile shows how sreal womangly narrative can override perception.
Selective social constructivism: Race is declared a pure social construct when that claim is useful, yet treated as rigid and essential when a different political goal is in play. The hypothetical exposes the inconsistency: if living in Argentina can supposedly strip someone of “whiteness,” then the category was never being used as a stable descriptor.
Conspiracy and myth-making: The underlying “Claus in Argentina” story already thrives because it lets people keep a villain alive in the imagination. Layering a racial denial on top of it simply adds another layer of motivated disbelief.
In short, the hypothetical illustrates a culture in which factual description of ancestry and appearance is often secondary to political utility. When basic categories become negotiable according to the needs of a story, ordinary historical and biological reality becomes optional. That is the actual comment on present society.