Any other Shia muslims here?

[korg]

feature this thread

 

[ImSlackingOff]

I'm not Christian.

The characters are 16, not little kids. You also literally worship a pedophile rapist and view him as the perfect paragon of morality that all muslims should model their lives after.

We don't worship Muhammad (PBUH), he is a messenger of Allah. We worship the one true God
Also you can't apply modern assumptions to a much different historical context

 

[korg]

Also you can't apply modern assumptions to a much different historical context

ermmm actually....
Muslims claim that Muhammad is the perfect moral example for ALL of humanity
If it seems weird for 21st century humans that Muhammad married a 6 year old girl then he's not the perfect moral example
checkmate m*d

 

[Keyed zaryan]

We don't worship Muhammad (PBUH), he is a messenger of Allah. We worship the one true God
Also you can't apply modern assumptions to a much different historical context

he said aisha was his favourite wife. Also if you think mohammed acted in a morally bad way, can you please explicitly condemn him and his actions?

 

[ImSlackingOff]

ermmm actually....
Muslims claim that Muhammad is the perfect moral example for ALL of humanity
If it seems weird for 21st century humans that Muhammad married a 6 year old girl then he's not the perfect moral example
checkmate m*d

When the prophet was a child the angel Gabriel was sent to cleanse his heart and remove his inclination to sin
Perfection only exists in the divine, Muhammad (PBUH) is only a human like all of us

 

[korg]

When the prophet was a child the angle Gabriel was sent to cleanse his heart and remove his inclination to sin
Perfection only exists in the divine, Muhammad (PBUH) is only a human like all of us

This didn't directly answer my question
Plus Muslims claim that Muhammad is completely sinless
You're making it sounding as if Muhammad could ever sin (from a Muslim perspective)

 

[ImSlackingOff]

he said aisha was his favourite wife. Also if you think mohammed acted in a morally bad way, can you please explicitly condemn him and his actions?

Aisha's real age was never fully confirmed, it is still debated to this day

 

[Keyed zaryan]

Aisha's real age was never fully confirmed, it is still debated to this day

It wasn't controversial until the 1900s when they suddenly "discovered" that he was actually 10 years older than all scholars had agreed for a millennia.

 

[ImSlackingOff]

This didn't directly answer my question
Plus Muslims claim that Muhammad is completely sinless
You're making it sounding as if Muhammad could ever sin (from a Muslim perspective)

No one said Muhammad was perfect, that's a common misconception, the Quran makes it clear that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was not perfect and that Allah had to correct his ways

 

[ImSlackingOff]

It wasn't controversial until the 1900s when they suddenly "discovered" that he was actually 10 years older than all scholars had agreed for a millennia.

There's no time limit for debate

 

[Keyed zaryan]

There's no time limit for debate

You don't think it's weird at all that they suddenly discovered a new interpretation the moment the average person started being morally opposed to the universally accepted interpretation that had been accepted for over 1000 years?

 

[ImSlackingOff]

You don't think it's weird at all that they suddenly discovered a new interpretation the moment the average person started being morally opposed to the universally accepted interpretation that had been accepted for over 1000 years?

Maybe, I'm not sure they only started contesting him age during the 20th century though

 

[korg]

No one said Muhammad was perfect, that's a common misconception, the Quran makes it clear that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was not perfect and that Allah had to correct his ways

Maybe not perfect in the divine sense, but the majority of Muslims still believe he's sinless and infallible

 

[korg]

Maybe, I'm not sure they only started contesting him age during the 20th century though

isn't that a little shitoko though?

 

[ImSlackingOff]

Maybe not perfect in the divine sense, but the majority of Muslims still believe he's sinless and infallible

he is free from all minor sins (human errors)
he never claimed to be perfect and sinless https://quran.com/abasa

 

[Goot]

No lol Christ is king

Wasn't it thay the shia recognise Jesus as a holy being or something?

 

[revolutionary]

Wasn't it thay the shia recognise Jesus as a holy being or something?

all muslims do

 

[Nihilma]

You know we are all white here right

...

 

[Nihilma]

Also, he's not a muslim he's a catholic, don't know what you seem to imply that he's a muslim.

 

[Lombard_Loressi]

What’s the point of this forum ?