November 18th, 2026 (Continued): "...So we took a season of about six months and we read the Catechism together uh Catechism of the Catholic Church, we prayed together I read a number of things kind of particular things that I had questions of some of the books are over there and at the end of that six months any questions that I had remaining were were done. I was ready to leave, to return to the church. So um I went to confession for the first time and I couldn't actually even remember what I I think what I told um my confessor was that this is my first confession in, I don't know, over 15 years, but it had been a long time, since I was in high school. And then, as a family, we actually started going to Mass together. My wife was not Catholic at the time, but we started going to Mass together as a family, and that is really the best thing that we did, because that brought us into contact with ordinary and faithful Catholics, who had a faith and a love for Jesus that we recognized very deeply, and this was a really compelling witness to us. And my wife often says, or we'll say now if you ask her, that for her, the first moment in which the light turned on for her, the first instance of, there's something here that I want to be part of, was that our fifth child, our Joseph, was born during this period, the kind of initial period of returning to the faith when we were going to Mass as a family. And so we had him baptized in our parish in North Carolina, and she was really moved by the baptism, and just by kind of everything that went with it, and thought, there's something here that I want to be part of. So she was eventually, about a year after that confirmed, went through OCIA as a mom of five, and thirty, what was she at the time, thirty-five, and was eventually received into the Church. And I suppose I can say more about, did you have other?” - The Lecturer
“No, I just have a few things. Yeah. Yeah.” A guy
“Thank you. What was the hardest part about the transition to Catholicism?” - A different guy
“The hardest part was, I think the hardest part was the uprooting from a community. So in North Carolina, when we moved there for me to start graduate school, we became members of a Presbyterian church that was right across from campus. It was a vibrant and really amazing community, and I still think that today. Really amazing people. And we were rooted in that community for eight or nine years before we left. And we had one set of friends that were Catholic, but we knew no other Catholics in the area. And all of our friends were not only Protestants, but most if not all of them went to this parish. So for us, really the hardest thing, and many, many tears were shed about this, was just the raw fact of leaving that church and then driving to a Catholic church that we had never been part of. And going into Maine, the first time that we went to Mass, as a family, I'll just forget this, the first time I went to Mass, we actually went down to the cathedral in Raleigh. And I'm just sort of watching my wife and wondering, what in the world is she thinking? And so we finally get home and we put all the kids to bed. And I finally sort of muster up the courage to ask her: ‘So, what do you think?’ And she just burst into tears. She was like, she just, it was unthinkable that, not tears of joy, like tears of, that's where you're going. It was just so strange and so different to anything that she had ever known. You know, lines of people waiting for confession. The homily, of course, was something kind of deeply Marian, because the text was on the Blessed Mother that Sunday. All of it was just very, very strange to her. So that was really, for us, the heartbreak, just the concrete uprooting from a community that we knew really, really deeply and deep friendships in, and moving over into a brand new community where we knew nobody. And the faith was very strange to us. Was her family all Catholic, of course? No, none of her family are Catholic. Oh, my family, yes. Yeah, my, so my mom is a, yeah, my, all of my family is, was raised Catholic. Not all of them are actively practicing faith. Most of them are. Yeah I think my, I don't know, I often, I think my parents maybe were abused by the whole thing when I became a Protestant. I think there was some initial concern, like, is he being brainwashed? Is he, what's going on here? Is he part of a cult? I was not part of a cult. And then when I returned to the church, I remember calling my mom and saying, Hey, Mom, I'm at work. I'm getting a confession letter. Your marriage is not validated. And she was like, oh, wow, that's great. Yeah, absolutely. So I think there were, I'm actually really not sure what they made of it.” - The Lecturer
“Maybe they were surprised that you took all of this so seriously.” - Another guy
“Maybe, yeah, maybe a little bit like, I'm kind of a, I'm just a little bit of a strange bird in my family. No, I'm like, I'm kind of a strange, in general. But also among my family, I'm like, you know, I'm sort of unusually religious. That's probably something I would say. So I think the whole thing was probably a bit strange that I took it all seriously. Unsurprisingly, this was much more difficult for my wife's family. I think, yeah, what I would say is that, so I had, this was another difficulty. I had a very, very deep and close relationship with my father-in-law, her father, who was a pivotal mentor in my young life as a Christian. And I am, I think what I would say is that he summoned more grace and goodwill than I probably would have been able to in this position. In the sense that he still comes and visits and stays with us for a month every summer. And loves us deeply, and we continue to have a certain level of deep affinity. But it is actually an ongoing source of, it really kind of put a breach in our friendship. In the sense that we really, like, we can't get to the core of things in the way that we used to. Because I'm sort of, I'm on a different path. So you can just sort of, I've noticed this as we kind of get into conversations. We used to really be in lockstep all the way down. And now it's not, and that's, yeah, that's an ongoing source of pain. And I often think of, yeah, that's just part of the, part of the way I often think of the words of Jesus. And I sort of hesitate to apply these because this is a very small example. But the fact is that he promises that those who follow him, no one who leaves father and mother and houses and wives and children in this life will not receive a thousand times more in this age than they used to. Nothing that you leave behind now or tomorrow will not be returned to you.” - The Lecturer
“Yeah, that's a great question.” - Another guy
“I think maybe, maybe just to make a general comment. At first, I think one of the things that I learned most deeply as a Protestant, and that Catholics tend to learn from at least kind of the more evangelical Protestants, and maybe our learning, I see this more and more, is that just sort of evangelical spirit, that deep, a deep love for the scriptures, a kind of, yeah, a sort of more, a more personally active expression of the faith. And even, I would say, the kind of like evangelistic spirit, going out and sharing the faith with others, which was just kind of part of the life of the evangelical churches that I was a part of. A very, in some ways a very simple trust in and love for our Lord, and a love for the scriptures. And a kind of genuine expression of that from the heart, that I think has continued to, that continues to shape who I am. In terms of particular, particular denominations, yeah, I mean, in some ways my journey kind of was up the ladder, as it were. So I sort of started in the most non-liturgical traditions, in sort of non-denominational churches, and then moved into the Presbyterian, sort of Baptists in the Presbyterian churches, where there's a little bit more of kind of a sense of, these are the things that we believe, and there are confessions that you kind of subscribe to. And then moved into kind of Anglicanism, which is kind of a step even closer to Catholicism, with the higher liturgy. So I suppose each of them was kind of a lily pad, as it were, into the next. It got me like one step closer, and like, I don't really want to end up over there, but I'll kind of try this one. Okay, yeah, this one. Yeah, I mean the, Yeah, I mean the, so, I mean, certainly the Rosary in particular was, you know, it was kind of a, you know, sort of like the relic, right? It's one of those, it's one of those things that, you know, some of you, I'm sure, have Protestant friends, and maybe you've had experiences like you kind of, you can go along for a long time, and you're like, yeah, yeah, we're, you know, we're kind of, we share the same faith, and then you pull out your Rosary, and it's like, oh wow, we're in different worlds. I think for me, so the way that I worked through this was actually just, I had a mentor, a Catholic professor, and I just asked him one day, like, you need to help me understand what's going on with the Rosary. And it's an old German professor, who's actually been, just recently appointed by Pope Leo to the International Theological Commission. But he said, I'm paraphrasing him, but, he said: “oh, the Rosary, well, the Rosary is a prayer centered on the life of Jesus.’ I thought, it is? I thought it was about Mary. So that was the first kind of opening for me, like, oh, actually, obviously the Rosary is, you pray the Rosary, you pray the beads, with decades of Hail Mary's, but actually the thing that it's fundamentally about is a meditation on the life of our Lord. So that was the first key..."
[POST SPLIT INTO MULTIPLE PARTS DUE TO CHARACTER LIMIT]