>Hey, lil buddy...
  • Welcome. Registering and having your account be approved may take a while since there's only one guy checking and approving accounts and guestposts

log

Everything I post and everything below in this thread is released to the public under the CC0 license, posting in this thread retroactively confirms you are releasing all of your posts under the CC0 license:
Transcription of all previous posts (3-8-2024 - 6-30-2025)
Transcription of all previous posts (7-1-2025 - 12-31-2025)
Transcription of all previous posts (1-1-2026 - 6-30-2026)
Transcription of all previous posts (7-1-2026 - )
27490 - SoyBooru.png
 
Last edited:
November 18th, 2026: Wednesday, I woke up at 6:25pm and got out of bed, making myself cereal and then brushing my teeth before packing up to head to work, I drove there and got in but Ultramarine was already there and in his cubicle, I got to finishing up the pull request I need to make to hit my daily quota before lunch and then I met another guy whom I will be calling Phthalo who has thinning hair with glasses, and another whom I will be calling Purpureus that drove with Adam II, Phthalo, and I to this tropical themed restaurant for the Wednesday lunch at 11:30am. I got in and we were there with 10 other (including me) to get seated, it was mostly White people’s version of Mexican food and I sat next to Indigo’s boss who has been here for at least 30 years. I ordered these enchiladas as I was the first one to be asked what I wanted and randomly said that with Dr Pepper (they had Dr Pibb instead) I ate and Adam II and I did a silent prayer. I saw Ultramarine on his phone a bit which reminded me that the new Jojolands chapter so I picked up my phone and read the chapter titled The Terrifying Dragnet, Part 1. I liked it, especially the design of the spiderweb stand and some people think ‘Dragnet’ is a reference to the 1979 album by The Fall, especially as it has a song on it titled A Figure Walks, in reference to the previously introduced light rod stand. I think Ultramarine might have had plastic surgery in order to looksmax. We left and I paid roughly $20. I got back to working, slowly making progress on coding my thing, I got on for a Deshi training thing as I messaged another employee at 2:45pm to get on a call with her so I could resolve the issue for a moment as she manually flagged one module as completed. I did roughly two hours of studying before it was 4:50pm and I left a bit early to beat the traffic and pick up my stuff from a dry cleaner. I took a different route off the highway through the streets, one that was on hillier roads but far less traffic. I was getting closer to my home when on this worn down road my car suddenly decided to start shutting down due to the suspension having issues. I was lucky enough to pull into a high school parking lot and try to get it started to no avail, yet when I decided to record the issue, my car started up again. I made a brief stop at my home to then walk over to the dry cleaner and pick up my Billy London UK Blazer then walked to the Catholic center for the speech by that one teacher I met over a year ago. Melany, Markus, and Lewis were there amongst at least 10 other men as we had tacos for dinner. Rita dropped in briefly and she said to me:
“Thank you so much Gemerson for taking and posting those photos yesterday!”
I said I was welcome and then Father Aquinas told us to move some stuff for the speech, mostly chairs, I took over a recliner by myself and then started recording:
"Welcome to our first official formation night of the year, semester. So tonight, Dr. [last name] is joining us, and you've probably seen him around. His office is upstairs, here at the Catholic center. He was involved, yeah, he's been involved with the Catholic center. He had an office in the location of the old building, too. We do stuff with the old building. So yeah, he's going to come, and we are just, like, intentionally having ways for you guys to grow intellectually, emotionally, spiritually throughout the year. We just really desire students to be, like, fully formed, well-formed Catholics here. So we're going to have Dr. [last name] as a great resource for us. So yeah, we'll just hear a little bit about his story, a little about his conversion, and then we'll have some time for questions at the end. So if you have any questions, please ask, and yeah, thank you guys for being here.” - Melany
“Thanks, Melany. I've got a little handout that I'll send around, so maybe you could just pull those, just take one of these and pass it around. I've also got a stack of books here. I'm used to people, like, falling asleep and getting up and walking away, so I figured I'd bring a bunch of stuff for you to look at while I'm talking to you. So these are a range of books. These are various books that either influenced me along the way, or some of them are kind of books on particular topics in Catholic thought, what Catholics believed that, for me, when I was Protestant, were very, kind of, really difficult issues, things that I thought Catholics were just crazy to think of. So you can feel free to look through that stack when it's available. And I'll pass them around. I'll refer to a couple of them. Actually, I'll turn this one here. I'm going to tell a version of my story, but if you want the full version, it's actually printed in this book. I've got a couple of prints in my head of this book, The Burning of the New Devils. I went to graduate school at Duke, and a whole bunch of us became Catholic there, sort of together as friends, but also independently. And because the impact was so great, I wanted to consider that not only we, but then eventually our wives and then our children came in as sort of a multiplication of the fishes and the loaves. So we collected the stories together. I'm going to create a fuller version in there if you like. The story of my life is not really all that interesting, but I really had sort of two conversions. So I was actually raised as a Catholic, baptized, confirmed in the church, went to Catholic school, actually graduated from the same Catholic high school in 2008 that my grandparents graduated from in 1935 and 1936. Small town, north central Ohio, deep Catholic roots, but I was poorly informed. So when I was in high school and I was going on to college, I was just chasing the typical American dream, which was girls, sports. So my first conversion was to religious Christianity, and I was sort of promised to become a Christian, and then a sort of second conversion about 12 years later. So that's kind of what I'll share the story in two stages. And I realized as I was putting together my notes for the talk that it's kind of always the temptation of telling a story is that it can be a sort of Catholic triumphalist story, like, oh, the church is great, and of course I would be happy if I could believe deeply in what the church taught and what the church teaches. But I thought in order to sort of counteract the tendency, I'd read actually a paragraph from a book, a favorite book of mine by an English historian called Saints and Sinners, A History of the Popes. And it's a very great book on the history of the popes. It's very thorough. He's a very great storyteller. For somewhat perverse reasons, one of my favorite chapters is on the popes in sort of the Renaissance period and the Reformation, which was a pretty bad time in the history of the church. So I'm going to read this as a sort of prophylactic against any sense that the church is just sort of created above history. Nothing to see here, folks. Nothing's ever been wrong. Nothing's ever been difficult. I'll say another word about it afterwards. So this is a period of the papacy from about 1450 to about 1520, so right on the kind of cusp of the Reformation. There's no accident that the Reformation happens. So he says, The Renaissance papacy evokes images of a Hollywood spectacular, all decadence and drag. Contemporaries viewed Renaissance Rome as we now view Nixon's Washington, a city of expense-account horrors and political graft, where everything and everyone had a price and nothing and nobody to be trusted. The popes themselves seemed to set the tone. Alexander VI, who was Pope of 1492-1503, flaunted a young and nubile mistress in the Vatican who was widely believed to have a habit of poisoning his cardinals so as to get his hands on their property, and he ruthlessly aggrandized his illegitimate sons and daughters at the church's expense. Julius II, who followed him, inspired pareal woman of Raphael, Bramante, Michelangelo, Leonardo, was a very dubious father of a faithful gringo father, three daughters of his own while he was a cardinal, and he was a ferocious and enthusiastic warrior dressing in silver papal armor and leading his own troops through the breaches, alone in the city walls and towns, where resistance was horrible. Last one, Leo X, the Pope apprehended three more of them. The son of Lorenzo the Magnificent of Florence was made a cleric at seven and a cardinal at thirteen. As Pope, he ruled both Rome and Florence. He was the Pope whose indulgence issued to fund the rebuilding of St. Peter's, and this led to him republishing his ninety-five theses in the Service of the Table. Okay, I don't read this just for shock value, though it is kind of shocking, but I was reminded, as I was just thinking about what I wanted to say to you all tonight, of a great line, and maybe you've heard this, but it's a great story that's told of an early nineteenth-century cardinal who met with Napoleon. He was on a rampage through Europe, and Napoleon at one point claimed that he was going to destroy the Church, and the cardinal just sort of laughed at it and said, 'Are you going to succeed in doing right here what we priests and bishops of the Church have failed to do for eighteen hundred years' which is destroy the Church?..."

[POST SPLIT INTO MULTIPLE PARTS DUE TO CHARACTER LIMIT]
 
November 18th, 2026 (Continued): "...Again, the point of the story is that, I think, one of the great testaments of the Church, of the truth of the Catholic faith, is that despite the saints and the sinners, and in this case particularly the sinners that have populated its history, people like you and me, that it remains at the gates of hell and not revealed. I take great courage in that, but it's one of the good things about knowing history, for those of you who are students of history, it's important, as Catholics, that we're able to give an account of that. Well, what about those quotes during the Renaissance? Let's talk about that. I meant to ask, though, before I start, how many of you here already are Catholic, or are in the process of becoming Catholic? Okay, so some of you may be at various points in the journey. Yeah, so like I say, I was raised in the Catholic Church, very poorly formed, and when I went to college, I had a My life was a mess. I went on a golf scholarship, and basically poured my life I went to a little school in Alabama, University of Montevallo. It's a little Division II school. Yeah, I poured my life into the party scene, and into sports. So this is really not a good recipe for living a healthy life. So by the time I was kind of a year into school, things did not look very good. And in the mystery of God's providence, I had a roommate who had gotten involved in a kind of evangelical campus ministry. He said, you should come along with me, and join in on these people. So for reasons that I still don't understand, I agreed to do this. I went along and ended up in a Bible study. And over the course of probably about a year, my life just totally turned upside down. So this is I'm going to read a couple of these quotations here. A couple of things I think that, looking back on this time, that struck me in a particular way that really kind of were the instruments, I suppose, that God used to, as I've quoted here, awake, oh sleeper. Awake, oh sleeper, arise from the dead. I was the walking dead. Just a sleepwalking through life. One of the insights that was given to me was about the nature of desire. I can still actually remember the couch that I was sitting on in my friend's house when I first read this quotation from C.S. Lewis. This is from a great essay. I think I have the collection over there. C.S. Lewis's collected essay is The Weight of Glory. It's a talk that he gave sometime during the war years. But this is what he says. Excuse me: ‘If we consider the unblushing promises of reward and the staggering nature of the rewards promised in the Gospels, it would seem that our Lord finds our desires not too sreal womang, but too weak. We are half-hearted creatures, fooling about with drink and sex and ambition when infinite joy is offered us. Like an ignorant child who wants to go on making mud pies in a slum because he cannot imagine what is meant by the offer of a holiday at the sea, we are far too easily pleased.’ This was just staggering to me. It was undoubtedly a moment of grace that I was able to register what Lewis was saying here. This ran directly against everything I had thought my entire life, which is that the faith in which I was raised, the moral vision of the Catholic life, the obligations and duties that are placed upon you, is really a kind of. I experienced that in the same way that I experienced the rules in the home. It's like, you can have so much fun, but no more. You can have so much joy, but no more. Your desires, we need to bring those in. The possibility that actually my desires were not sreal womang enough, but actually too weak, that I was a half-hearted creature like the child who is content to make mud pies in a slum because he actually just can't imagine what's meant by going on a holiday at the sea was Yeah, it just sort of upended my world. I thought, wow, I had never considered that possibility. And I think it also struck me at a particular moment. I had given myself to precisely these things, drink, and sex, and ambition, and had found actually this was not bringing anything like the kind of joy that I thought it was going to bring. So I was well-friendly here. So that was the first sort of alarm bell, as it were. The second one was closely related to this, and this was the nature of freedom. Again, I thought that in pursuing the life that I was pursuing, I was chasing unbridled freedom. I want to live the way that I want to live, and I don't want anyone to put restraints on what I want to do. If I want to do this, I'm going to do that. And I don't need the Church to tell me not to do this. But then, sort of along this journey, I encountered these words from the Gospel of John. This is an exchange Jesus is having with his disciples…”
John 8:31-34

☛31 Jesus said to the Jews who had believed in him: ‘If you continue in my word, you are truly my disciples,
☛32 and you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.
☛33 They answered him, We are descendants of Abraham, and have never been in bondage to anyone. How is it that you say you will be made free?
☛34 Jesus answered them, Truly, truly, I say to you, everyone who commits sin is a slave to sin.

“...John chapter 8. I certainly was experiencing at the time that last part, which is that sort of the seductive labor of sin. There's a great image in Dante's Purgatorio where this sort of very attractive woman presents himself to Dante and sort of enticing him to come along. And then at some point, Virgil appears and kind of rips her open, and she just oozes this disgusting filth on the inside. It's just a great image of sin. It has kind of a seductive allure to it. But on the inside, it's disgusting. Or this is what it leads to. But the possibility, so I was certainly kind of experiencing that in my own life, but the possibility that I was sort of enslaved to my desire and needed to be set free had never occurred to me. And it certainly had never occurred to me that the truth could be an instrument of liberation for me. I remember being given the analogy like, well, you know, Aaron, you're sort of living as if, right, you were sort of a fish in a fish tank and somebody said, oh, poor thing, it's trapped in this tank and sort of scooped you out and put you on the ground. Now you're free to go. Well, no, you're not going to be free for very long because you're going to die. You're not meant to live under those conditions. But actually the right sort of conditions are precisely the things that set you free. So, these two sort of ideas, nature of desire and the nature of freedom and the possibility of disordered desire and slavery really, really just struck like a lightbulb in my life. And again, I think I was primed to hear them, perhaps in a way that I had not been before. And then a third, I think a third kind of aspect of my sort of first conversion, what I'm calling it, had to do with a sense of deep purpose in life. Again, I was giving my life to things that I had taken great joy in for much of my life, sports and friendships and ambition. But you find, and maybe you've had this experience, you find that if you, the longer that you give your life to things that are not worthy of the weight of your life, the sort of hollower they feel in the end. And you sort of realize, this thing feels vain. This thing is not meant to sort of bear the weight of my life. I remember being in a Bible study with some friends and this verse here from Acts chapter 20 was sort of the theme verse for the year. And I really think it gave me a vision of a sense of deep purpose in life that's really stayed with me since then. This is St. Paul speaking in the Acts of the Apostles. He says…”
Acts 20:24

☛23 But I do not account my life of any value, nor as precious to myself, if only I may accomplish my course in the ministry which I received from the Lord Jesus, to testify to the gospel of the grace of God.
“...Yeah, just a sort of beautiful sense that this man, I felt in some ways similar to the Apostle Paul, sort of lived your whole life in a certain way and then realized wow, I've been living false my whole life. Kind of this dramatic sense of reorientation. But in Paul's case, he had quite a lot of things that he might have held precious. He had quite a good pedigree. We would say today he had quite a good resume, quite a good CV. But so surpassing to him was the call that he had received from the Lord in the sense of giving his full life to God. That he accounted his life as really of no value, if only he could do the work of the Lord. I think again, this just really, I saw this embodied in the community that I was a part of, but there was kind of a sense that a deep and high and noble sense of calling. That my life can be spent in the service of something that transcends my own desires, which are sort of fleeting and vain. So with the combination of these three things, there's much else besides, but these are the things that come first to mind. My life really turned around in a pretty dramatic way when I was an undergraduate. But this happened through, as I mentioned earlier, kind of an evangelical Protestant campus ministry. And so I also at that time reacted really sreal womangly against the Catholicism in which I was raised. I thought this stuff is, you know, I wondered at first, not unreasonably, why had I never heard of this before?..."

[POST SPLIT INTO MULTIPLE PARTS DUE TO CHARACTER LIMIT]
 
November 18th, 2026 (Continued): "...St. John Henry Newman wrote a book on the time there he was an Anglican priest through the 19th century for the first half of his life he was an Anglican priest very similar kind of story became a historian of the early church and about halfway through his life converted to Catholicism and this is at a time when this was sort of unthinkable it's like defecting to the Soviet Union or something and so this he's writing this book really to kind of explore could it really be possible that Catholicism is true and this is what he writes and this one thing at least is certain whatever history teaches whatever it omits whatever it exaggerates or extenuates whatever it says or unsays at least the Christianity at least at least the Christianity of history is not Protestantism if ever there were a safe truth it was this Protestantism has ever felt itself he's saying that because he's actually just commented on the fact that there are many great Protestant theologians coming out of the Reformation but there's the only one who's written actually something even approaching the history of the Church is an unbeliever Edward Gibbon wrote a The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire..."
[Note: Edward Gibbon is a fat cacaot burning in hell]
"...and that's certainly what I was beginning to feel myself I had expected to find confirmation of my Protestantism in the early Church and I was finding instead that it was very Catholic so this this unsettled me. A second kind of part of my reversion, my return to the Catholic Church is summarized very very concisely in this quotation on Catholicity from G.K. Chesterton I'll read this try to unpack a little bit it's a great essay from Chesterton Why I'm Catholic he says that: ‘Catholicism is the only type of Christianity that really contains every type of man’ okay what does he mean by that? one of the things that I had experienced in Protestantism and I had been in various different kinds of of Protestant Church I've been in Baptist Churches I've been in Non-Denomination Churches I've been in Presbyterian Churches I've been in Anglican Churches and kind of found myself wandering through different Protestant strands as I was searching for my experience of one denomination was that boy, it's really good on X, Y, and Z but it really doesn't have this other piece it's sort of really good for a while I was actually for most of my time I was a kind of Reformed Presbyterian really good stuff really sharp intellectually but not a really deep living spiritual tradition so I was kind of constantly felt like I was sort of grabbing from different pieces of each tradition trying to cobble something together from all the different traditions to sort of make up Christianity and the image that I that I'll give you of this that came to me later my experience of as I kind of got deeper into the study of the Catholic faith and deeper into the study of the history of the Church was that the image of kind of a Basilica a great church so if you can imagine entering through if you've ever been just the Basilica of St. Josephat or if you've ever been to Rome a really big a really big church you enter through the front doors and it's a cavernous space an enormous space the altar's way up there in the front there's more church behind the altar the arms stretch out on the side of the altar you're sort of just like, wow this is an enormous space but there's also kind of running the walls these sort of like little nooks maybe like a side altar here or just like a little prayer area over here what I was kind of the sort of image that this suggests that I think is fitting here is that my experience of being in these sort of various Protestant communities was that it was like being in one of those little nooks it was like, I could sort of we had our own it was a really nice area it was a really nice area to pray, and you could kind of like sometimes poke around into the neighboring one and say you got over there, interesting, and you could see out into the larger area but you kind of had a you were sort of tucked in a corner a little bit you were off to the periphery and my increasingly my experience of what I was seeing in the Catholic faith was all these things that were kind of divided up and parceled into different bits. Protestant communities were found together it was like coming out of that little nook into the main space wow, this place is huge you've got Dominicans and Franciscans I mean, sometimes they hate each other but they still go to Mass together. You've got diverse kinds of spiritualities you've got someone like St. Thomas Aquinas who is, you know, most known to us as the greatest theologian in the Church's history but he also I mean, at the end of his life had a mystical vision in which as he was following upon his perception of the Eucharist he said: ‘everything that I've written is straw!’ I have a really deep mysticism the idea that these two things could go together that you could have a really deep spirituality and be a nerd and love theology these two things at least in my experience are very common in Catholicism, but it was just the case over and over again most of the great saints of the Church or I should say all of the doctors of the Church are not only great teachers of the Church but they are first saints which is to say, they have a very deep living spirituality so I kind of had this my experience of Catholicism as I was kind of understanding it more and more was that it brought together into a whole what I found only kind of scattered pieces and the thing that's so fitting about this is that Catholic actually comes from. it's sort of put together from two Greek words, Catholic just is according to the whole that was the experience of the faithful that's where everything is here together I'll get on to that. So that was the second piece and then the third piece that I'll mention in closing here had to do with the nature of faith and scripture and tradition so one of the real roadblocks for me was that there we go, thank you. I think one of the final roadblocks for me was that I had a really difficult time with the Church's understanding of authority and I had a hard time understanding how it could be that um well, I really had no way to understand how the Church herself um was an extension of the Lord's authority and not as I thought kind of a human authority um speaking authoritatively about the scriptures I felt that becoming Catholic would have been submitting myself kind of arbitrarily to another human authority and that the only sure guide in the Christian life are the scriptures and the Word of God and that, they are they are a sure guide um but what I began to notice kind of the deeper I got into the study of the faith. The first time I remember noticing this I remember thinking oh, interesting, I've changed my mind about that. I used to think that the scriptures taught X um for example I used to think that it was very clear in scriptures that um that man is justified by faith alone I thought this was very clear um I, in the course of being in seminary in graduate school changed my mind when I discovered oh, actually this is kind of more complex than I thought um in fact, Saint James says at one point man is not justified by faith alone um St. Paul talks about faith working through love so I sort of began to notice maybe the scriptures aren't quite as uh quite as clear as I made them out to be or at least um I'm having to do a lot of interpreting here um I'm bringing a kind of my own powers of judgment to bear on the scriptures in pretty significant ways. So I'll read two quotations from the back here, the first, a very short one from the one on scripture and tradition from St. Francis de Sales it's a really great book if you have deeper questions about the nature of Catholicism or kind of how it sort of Protestant response to sorry Catholic response to Protestantism, de Sales is a great voice on this he was the bishop of Geneva in the late 16th century at a time when Geneva as a whole had been had kind of fully gone over to Protestantism, and he really kind of re-evangelized or re-converted much of the area, but he has this very pithy question um in his in this work of his he says: ‘If scripture be the subject of our disagreement who shall decide?’ in other words he finds himself in these disputes with Protestants and the disagreement can't simply be resolved by appealing to scripture because the problem is they disagree about what the passage of scripture means um and this is about he refers to the Eucharist in this case he refers to justification in this case he refers to kind of the nature of the church um in all these areas the problem is not the problem actually can't be resolved simply by appealing to scripture the problem is that they disagree about its meaning so then what do you do? Francis de Sales point is that actually this kind of shows the insufficiency of the classic Protestant doctrine of scripture alone because scripture is never alone, somebody's always interpreting it so I was beginning to kind of experience this in my own life like. I'm actually the one who's doing a lot of interpreting here I don't like the Pope doing that, but I seem to be doing kind of a lot of it myself um I was also experiencing the quotation on faith um it really began to sort of characterize my life. Saint John Henry Newman again, I've already mentioned him but a really profound influence um this is from his essay on faith and private judgment he says:

[POST SPLIT INTO MULTIPLE PARTS DUE TO CHARACTER LIMIT]
 
November 18th, 2026 (Continued): "...‘If scripture be the subject of our disagreement who shall decide?’ in other words he finds himself in these disputes with Protestants and the disagreement can't simply be resolved by appealing to scripture because the problem is they disagree about what the passage of scripture means um and this is about he refers to the Eucharist in this case he refers to justification in this case he refers to kind of the nature of the church um in all these areas the problem is not the problem actually can't be resolved simply by appealing to scripture the problem is that they disagree about its meaning so then what do you do? Francis de Sales point is that actually this kind of shows the insufficiency of the classic Protestant doctrine of scripture alone because scripture is never alone, somebody's always interpreting it so I was beginning to kind of experience this in my own life like. I'm actually the one who's doing a lot of interpreting here I don't like the Pope doing that, but I seem to be doing kind of a lot of it myself um I was also experiencing the quotation on faith um it really began to sort of characterize my life. Saint John Henry Newman again, I've already mentioned him but a really profound influence um this is from his essay on faith and private judgment he says: ‘Since men nowadays deduce from scripture instead of believing a teacher you may expect to see them waver about to see them waver about they will feel the force of their own deductions their own conclusions more sreal womangly at one time than at another they'll change their minds about them or perhaps deny them altogether whereas this cannot be while a man has faith that is, belief that what a preacher says to him comes from God.’ In other words, what Newman is saying is that it's characteristic of um in which you take your teaching from your own reading of scripture that you're likely to change your mind about this from time to time as you study the scriptures more deeply as you engage in conversation with people and discover oh, interesting, I hadn't thought of it in that way I hadn't thought of it in this way um it's characteristic that you kind of waver about and you change your mind I was experiencing this as I moved sort of from one Protestant denomination to another maybe that's not quite right maybe this is right um and what Newman goes on to say is that it's actually what's characteristic of faith um it's not that the question of faith is not what are the doctrines of the gospel but who is the teacher who is the divinely appointed who has God appointed um to be the teacher of truth and you can see this um once that kind of once that becomes clear to you you can actually see this very clearly on the pages of scripture um in his in his letter to Thessalonians, St. Paul tells them hold fast to the traditions um that I've handed on to you whether by word of mouth or by writing um that when the Lord was taken up and ascended into heaven um He did not simply give them a collection of books He actually invested His authority in His apostles and that they continue to invest that authority in those who come after them so that there will be a reliable living voice that can speak into the questions that inevitably arise in the church. So the kind of combination of all these things and much else I could say especially the witness of deep friendships that I had um eventually brought me to a point where I thought I um I have to I have to take this seriously um I can no longer kind of keep at bay all the kind of I keep raising these objections and they keep getting knocked down um I was for a while a very reluctant um revert to the church, but eventually um realized to my to my great surprise that this faith that I thought I had rejected um as a 19-year-old was actually true, after all I had misunderstood it for a long time um but it was actually true. Now last kind of note before I'm happy to take questions here. And I've provided a few here to kind of um just prompt some thinking but you know what? I've often reflected on the fact that I really owe my the fullness the kind of living Catholic faith that I have now to the many years that I was um kind of lovingly and zealously formed in Protestant churches I believe that very very deeply um and I think often of and pray often for the many friends and mentors and pastors that I had along the way and for a while this was kind of a difficulty for me I didn't quite know how um what what to make of this or I didn't have a kind of clean way to make sense of it um and then a couple years ago I read this passage from Lumen Gentium this is a document from the Second Vatican Council it's the Constitution of the Church and I just think this paragraph captures when I read this I thought that's exactly um what I it just put its finger on um my experience so um the the Council Fathers write this is the one: ”This is the vector of truth this is the one this is the one Church of Christ which in the Creed is professed as one holy, catholic and apostolic which our Saviour after His Resurrection commissioned to Peter to shepherd and Him and the other Apostles to extend and direct with authority which He erected for the ages as the pillar and mainstay of truth…’ That's a quotation from 1st Timothy , 2nd Timothy, one of the Timothys I can't remember um this Church constituted and organized in the world as a society subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the bishops in communion with him that's what it is to be in the full communion of the Catholic Church. Although and here's the key point although many elements of sanctification and of truth are found outside of its visible structure, these elements as gifts belonging to the Church of Christ are forces impelling toward Catholic unit. If I could put that another way this gave expression to the sense that I long had which is that I had found real sources of truth and sanctification in the many Protestant Communions, that I had been formed in and I still think that that's the case what I sort of discovered in hindsight was that as I kind of you know if all of these are sort of threads of truth um uh threads of truth and sanctification as I kind of followed each of these threads. All of them eventually led me to the fullness of the Catholic faith if you sort of trace each one of them out um so I just have found this um a really beautiful way of being able kind of just even in my own heart in my own prayer, to be deeply thankful for the um the many wonderful Protestant friends that I have had and still have that formed me deeply and whose example continues to inspire me while also um while also being able to give an account of why those things led me. Back to the Catholic Church, okay. I have some questions here, I'm happy to take any of these. I'm also happy if you have um particular questions about Catholicism or about Protestantism kind of from yourself um difficulties that you findwith with the Catholic faith or things that you've wondered about um I'm wide open. Happy to take questions.” - The Lecturer
“Just to tie it on just real practically like like what did that actually look like? You know, you were in the seminary but you also forgot things like…” - A guy
“Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's a lot I left out.” - The Lecturer
“Yeah, so” - A guy
“As Father says, I met my wife in New Zealand which is actually where I started in seminary. I was an accounting major as an undergrad moved to New Zealand intending to be there for six months, met my wife and got married there um and started in the seminary there. We so the maybe a couple of the kind of practical details. By the time that so we ended up coming to the U.S. um I went to Duke for graduate school and then started in a master's program. Ended up doing a Ph.D. in theology it was during the course of that Ph.D. that I was received back into the Church. Um part of the reason that it took a long time is because by the time I had begun to wonder when this first came on my horizon like I think for a while I just couldn't imagine entertaining this question. I had rejected Catholicism really hard as a 19-year-old like really hard. Um and there were a couple of moments along the way in which I thought I might be wrong about one or two things here but I just I couldn't even entertain the possibility of it. Um I think part of the reason that it took so long to really take it seriously was that by the by the time I did. We had four children and we were pregnant with our fifth. So it wasn't just a matter of me you know kind of making my own decision but this was going to uproot our family from the community that we had been nurtured in. My wife's father is a Presbyterian pastor so she's a pastor's kid. The kind of Protestant faith runs very deep in the family. Um so this was a huge uprooting for our family. Um it did turn out to be that but it was at the time it was um it would delay in the future. Um so eventually uh what the kind of the way it played out was that my wife, because she's extraordinarily holy uh sort of took all this in good will and said: ‘wow um that's not where I'm at um but it sounds like these things are really important to you and it sounds like we need to pray about them.’..."

[POST SPLIT INTO MULTIPLE PARTS DUE TO CHARACTER LIMIT]
 
November 18th, 2026 (Continued): "...So we took a season of about six months and we read the Catechism together uh Catechism of the Catholic Church, we prayed together I read a number of things kind of particular things that I had questions of some of the books are over there and at the end of that six months any questions that I had remaining were were done. I was ready to leave, to return to the church. So um I went to confession for the first time and I couldn't actually even remember what I I think what I told um my confessor was that this is my first confession in, I don't know, over 15 years, but it had been a long time, since I was in high school. And then, as a family, we actually started going to Mass together. My wife was not Catholic at the time, but we started going to Mass together as a family, and that is really the best thing that we did, because that brought us into contact with ordinary and faithful Catholics, who had a faith and a love for Jesus that we recognized very deeply, and this was a really compelling witness to us. And my wife often says, or we'll say now if you ask her, that for her, the first moment in which the light turned on for her, the first instance of, there's something here that I want to be part of, was that our fifth child, our Joseph, was born during this period, the kind of initial period of returning to the faith when we were going to Mass as a family. And so we had him baptized in our parish in North Carolina, and she was really moved by the baptism, and just by kind of everything that went with it, and thought, there's something here that I want to be part of. So she was eventually, about a year after that confirmed, went through OCIA as a mom of five, and thirty, what was she at the time, thirty-five, and was eventually received into the Church. And I suppose I can say more about, did you have other?” - The Lecturer
“No, I just have a few things. Yeah. Yeah.” A guy
“Thank you. What was the hardest part about the transition to Catholicism?” - A different guy
“The hardest part was, I think the hardest part was the uprooting from a community. So in North Carolina, when we moved there for me to start graduate school, we became members of a Presbyterian church that was right across from campus. It was a vibrant and really amazing community, and I still think that today. Really amazing people. And we were rooted in that community for eight or nine years before we left. And we had one set of friends that were Catholic, but we knew no other Catholics in the area. And all of our friends were not only Protestants, but most if not all of them went to this parish. So for us, really the hardest thing, and many, many tears were shed about this, was just the raw fact of leaving that church and then driving to a Catholic church that we had never been part of. And going into Maine, the first time that we went to Mass, as a family, I'll just forget this, the first time I went to Mass, we actually went down to the cathedral in Raleigh. And I'm just sort of watching my wife and wondering, what in the world is she thinking? And so we finally get home and we put all the kids to bed. And I finally sort of muster up the courage to ask her: ‘So, what do you think?’ And she just burst into tears. She was like, she just, it was unthinkable that, not tears of joy, like tears of, that's where you're going. It was just so strange and so different to anything that she had ever known. You know, lines of people waiting for confession. The homily, of course, was something kind of deeply Marian, because the text was on the Blessed Mother that Sunday. All of it was just very, very strange to her. So that was really, for us, the heartbreak, just the concrete uprooting from a community that we knew really, really deeply and deep friendships in, and moving over into a brand new community where we knew nobody. And the faith was very strange to us. Was her family all Catholic, of course? No, none of her family are Catholic. Oh, my family, yes. Yeah, my, so my mom is a, yeah, my, all of my family is, was raised Catholic. Not all of them are actively practicing faith. Most of them are. Yeah I think my, I don't know, I often, I think my parents maybe were abused by the whole thing when I became a Protestant. I think there was some initial concern, like, is he being brainwashed? Is he, what's going on here? Is he part of a cult? I was not part of a cult. And then when I returned to the church, I remember calling my mom and saying, Hey, Mom, I'm at work. I'm getting a confession letter. Your marriage is not validated. And she was like, oh, wow, that's great. Yeah, absolutely. So I think there were, I'm actually really not sure what they made of it.” - The Lecturer
“Maybe they were surprised that you took all of this so seriously.” - Another guy
“Maybe, yeah, maybe a little bit like, I'm kind of a, I'm just a little bit of a strange bird in my family. No, I'm like, I'm kind of a strange, in general. But also among my family, I'm like, you know, I'm sort of unusually religious. That's probably something I would say. So I think the whole thing was probably a bit strange that I took it all seriously. Unsurprisingly, this was much more difficult for my wife's family. I think, yeah, what I would say is that, so I had, this was another difficulty. I had a very, very deep and close relationship with my father-in-law, her father, who was a pivotal mentor in my young life as a Christian. And I am, I think what I would say is that he summoned more grace and goodwill than I probably would have been able to in this position. In the sense that he still comes and visits and stays with us for a month every summer. And loves us deeply, and we continue to have a certain level of deep affinity. But it is actually an ongoing source of, it really kind of put a breach in our friendship. In the sense that we really, like, we can't get to the core of things in the way that we used to. Because I'm sort of, I'm on a different path. So you can just sort of, I've noticed this as we kind of get into conversations. We used to really be in lockstep all the way down. And now it's not, and that's, yeah, that's an ongoing source of pain. And I often think of, yeah, that's just part of the, part of the way I often think of the words of Jesus. And I sort of hesitate to apply these because this is a very small example. But the fact is that he promises that those who follow him, no one who leaves father and mother and houses and wives and children in this life will not receive a thousand times more in this age than they used to. Nothing that you leave behind now or tomorrow will not be returned to you.” - The Lecturer
“Yeah, that's a great question.” - Another guy
“I think maybe, maybe just to make a general comment. At first, I think one of the things that I learned most deeply as a Protestant, and that Catholics tend to learn from at least kind of the more evangelical Protestants, and maybe our learning, I see this more and more, is that just sort of evangelical spirit, that deep, a deep love for the scriptures, a kind of, yeah, a sort of more, a more personally active expression of the faith. And even, I would say, the kind of like evangelistic spirit, going out and sharing the faith with others, which was just kind of part of the life of the evangelical churches that I was a part of. A very, in some ways a very simple trust in and love for our Lord, and a love for the scriptures. And a kind of genuine expression of that from the heart, that I think has continued to, that continues to shape who I am. In terms of particular, particular denominations, yeah, I mean, in some ways my journey kind of was up the ladder, as it were. So I sort of started in the most non-liturgical traditions, in sort of non-denominational churches, and then moved into the Presbyterian, sort of Baptists in the Presbyterian churches, where there's a little bit more of kind of a sense of, these are the things that we believe, and there are confessions that you kind of subscribe to. And then moved into kind of Anglicanism, which is kind of a step even closer to Catholicism, with the higher liturgy. So I suppose each of them was kind of a lily pad, as it were, into the next. It got me like one step closer, and like, I don't really want to end up over there, but I'll kind of try this one. Okay, yeah, this one. Yeah, I mean the, Yeah, I mean the, so, I mean, certainly the Rosary in particular was, you know, it was kind of a, you know, sort of like the relic, right? It's one of those, it's one of those things that, you know, some of you, I'm sure, have Protestant friends, and maybe you've had experiences like you kind of, you can go along for a long time, and you're like, yeah, yeah, we're, you know, we're kind of, we share the same faith, and then you pull out your Rosary, and it's like, oh wow, we're in different worlds. I think for me, so the way that I worked through this was actually just, I had a mentor, a Catholic professor, and I just asked him one day, like, you need to help me understand what's going on with the Rosary. And it's an old German professor, who's actually been, just recently appointed by Pope Leo to the International Theological Commission. But he said, I'm paraphrasing him, but, he said: “oh, the Rosary, well, the Rosary is a prayer centered on the life of Jesus.’ I thought, it is? I thought it was about Mary. So that was the first kind of opening for me, like, oh, actually, obviously the Rosary is, you pray the Rosary, you pray the beads, with decades of Hail Mary's, but actually the thing that it's fundamentally about is a meditation on the life of our Lord. So that was the first key..."

[POST SPLIT INTO MULTIPLE PARTS DUE TO CHARACTER LIMIT]
 
November 18th, 2026 (Continued): "...And the second, closely related to that, was kind of a, I think a more, a better understanding, or at least a better starting place with understanding who the Blessed Mother is, and how to understand her role in the Catholic imagination. Again, my mentor said, you know, he took me to the John II, the wedding in Canaan, and Mary comes to Jesus and tells him, you're out of wine, and he says, well, now is not my time. She goes and gets the servants, and the servants come, and she directs the servants and says, do whatever he tells you. And the way that my mentor put it to me is, that's what the Blessed Mother is always doing, she's always pointing us to Christ, do whatever he tells you. That in a sense, she's not, she's not kind of sort of a figure on her own, but as a mother does, directs us to her son. So I think for me, that was a helpful starting place, because, okay, the Rosary is a meditation on the life of Christ, and the Blessed Mother is always directing me to her son. I think from there I've grown, and really, I just, you know, to be honest, I'm still, I'm not someone who, like a cradle Catholic, has a deep, kind of a deep and full Mary, it's really something I've still found myself growing. I often ask, increasingly ask for her intercession, but it's something that's come more by, more slowly and more by learning than actually. Well, as Melany says, my office is up in that top part, if you ever, yeah. So I, so the reason I have an office here is because I direct the St. Irenaeus Institute, maybe you've heard about this, you might have been here a couple weeks ago for an announcement, but we, the purpose of the St. Irenaeus Institute is to, it's very much born out of my own journey. This is not the case for everyone, but for many people, or at least for some people, for those of us who are nerds, deeper understanding of the truth can bring you closer to our, brings you closer to our Lord, and deepens your love for him. And so that, in many ways, that's what we're trying to do. I would say that our ultimate goal is to help people, including ourselves, become saints through acquiring wisdom and understanding. And so the Catholic center has that goal of becoming saints in different ways, just like kinship, same goal, but through different means. The way that we're trying to direct people to become saints is through wisdom and understanding, and deeper study and understanding of things. So we do this in a variety of ways. We host a couple lectures. There'll be a spring, or a winter lecture here at UW-Milwaukee in late February. I'm currently teaching a course, I'm an adjunct professor of religious studies here, teaching a course on early Christianity right now, so kind of the first couple centuries, sort of the Gospels and the early church, which is my academic background. And then in the spring, I won't be teaching, but someone better than me, our scholar-in-residence will be teaching Religious Studies 250, which is Catholic Thought and Culture. So it's kind of a basic introduction to, like, how have Catholics thought about and understood the faith, the practice of the faith, human life, prayer, all of these things. Kind of a sort of broad vision of the Catholic imagination. So that's Religious Studies 250 in the spring. That'll be a great course if you have It does count for... There's one of the Gen Eds that it counts for, I can't remember which one, but if you have room for it, I can sort of shamelessly promote it, because I'm not teaching it. So we do some lectures, four-credit courses. We'll also do some non-credit stuff in the spring. Melany and I are still working this out, but I'm going to do a Lenten kind of spiritual reading group, probably one of C.S. Lewis's books, that if you kind of would like a short, you know, sort of lower-stakes commitment, six weeks over Lent, we'll read maybe Lewis's Screwtape Letters together. And then we also do some other notes on Thursday evenings, if you wander up there. You might notice there's a bunch of people gathered around the table. We do some non-credit seminars as well. So in the spring, I'll be doing one on Catholic social thought, from Leo to Leo. So if you have... Yeah, those are some of the things that we do. And if that stuff is of interest to you, or just generally as you have questions about the faith, from any range of things, I can't promise to have answers to that, but I'm very happy to think with you about them.” - The Lecturer
“If you had to suggest one book to recommend to somebody who doesn't know much about Catholicism or even Christianity in general, what would that book be?” - Markus
“Well, those would be two different books. For someone who doesn't know anything about Christianity in general... Yeah, I think it really depends on where they're coming from. A couple things come to mind. I think, still for my money, C.S. Lewis is just one of the greatest Christian writers of all time. I mean, he's a great point of entry. His fiction and his non-fiction, you just can't go wrong, for the most part, with a book of C.S. Lewis. So I have a number of friends who initially became Christians from reading Peer Christianity. So that comes to mind first. From the question of, you know, if you know someone who's a Christian but not a Catholic and they would just like to learn more about Catholicism, I still think, now this is not a... To most people this is not a page-turner, but just as a point of reference and clarity of teaching and for richness, the Catechism is a fantastic, I mean, it's an amazing resource. If you're looking for something more of a story, there's a book by, maybe you've heard of Scott Hahn, it's a book called Rome, Sweet Home. It's written very autobiographically. He actually went to Marquette here in a very similar kind of story. He thought that he hated Catholicism and kind of wandered into a chapel and discovered, wow, I think this is true. And similarly, it took his wife longer to convert, so they tell their story in that book. It's very well told. That's probably a good point of entry.” - The Lecturer
“There's a podcast series called The Journey Home.” - Father Aquinas
“Oh, okay. No, I haven't.” - The Lecturer
“It's produced by EWTN. It's a TV show. It's by Spotify. It's The Journey Home. And every episode is like one hour of Protestant conversation. One who's converted. They're not flash shoots. It's an hour. And there's hundreds of episodes. Yeah, that's good.” - Father Aquinas
“I think hearing the stories of people who've converted, I have one in particular that comes to mind. I can provide a link to this to you if you'd like. But a friend of mine who teaches now at Providence College, Travis Lacey, who's one of the stories in that book, he has a really just fantastic… He grew up as an evangelical in Oklahoma. Again, probably had a sreal womanger aversion to Catholicism than I did. And has an interview. It's on YouTube. It's had several tens of thousands of views now. He has just a really compelling way of telling how he became Catholic without hating his old roots. It's always the trick, right? When you convert, you typically have a pretty sreal womang reaction against what you convert against. And that can always be a little bit of a danger in conversion stories. Maybe I transgressed that a little bit tonight. I hope I gave voice to the continuities for me that were from Protestantism to Catholicism. But Travis does this just exceptionally well. So I've actually listened to that a few times. It's a great interview. But these kinds of things are out there, and I think those are great resources. Well, thanks for your attention, friends. It's good to be with you. And I'm just always heartily encouraged by your faith and by your witness. And like I say, if there's any way that I can be of service to you, knock on my door and drop me a note.” - The Lecturer
“There are some little blind children running around. Those are his kids.” - Father Aquinas.
I got to talk to him a bit afterwards and found out his confirmation saint is Saint Francis de Sales. I walked back home and then took a shower before publishing my blogpost.

Song of the Day: Psykick Dancehall - The Fall (1979)
 
Back
Top Bottom